Drew Pasteur's Ohio Fantastic 50
Ohio High School Football Rankings and Predictions
Follow the Fantastic 50 on Twitter/X for the latest updates.
Scores & schedules courtesy of Joe Eitel
Newcomerstown Trojans history
Updated Mon 03-Nov-2025 11:34 AM
Week 11 complete
Season by season results
2025 7-4, #376, D6 #37
2024 9-3, #428, D6 #38, regional quarters (won 1)
2023 7-5, #530, D6 #63, regional quarters (won 1)
2022 8-3, #563, D6 #72, first round
2021 1-5, #663, D6 #98
2020 1-7, #657, D6 #97
2019 5-5, #521, D6 #66
2018 0-10, #662, D6 #95
2017 0-10, #688, D6 #107
2016 3-7, #612, D6 #91
2015 3-7, #601, D6 #86
2014 5-5, #496, D6 #61
2013 6-4, #451, D6 #48
2012 4-6, #572, D5 #90
2011 3-7, #608, D5 #98
2010 5-5, #535, D5 #86
2009 5-5, #537, D5 #81
2008 2-8, #690, D5 #118
2007 3-7
2006 1-9
2005 3-7
2004 2-8
2003 8-2
2002 7-3
Playoff record (since 2002): 2-4
Fantastic 50 ranking history
Highest overall ranking: #288 in 2024
Lowest overall ranking: #697 in 2017
Divisional top 10 ranking history
Highest divisional ranking: #15 in 2024
Lowest divisional ranking: #120 in 2008
Records against F50-ranked teams, 2008-2023
Record vs ranked teams: 0-0
Best win: 2024 #270 Toronto
Records against divisional top-10 ranked teams, 2008-2023
Record vs ranked teams: 0-7
Best win: 2024 #16 Toronto
Overall results since 2008
Overall record: 74-106
Longest overall winning streak: 7 (2024)
Longest overall losing streak: 24 (2016-18), currently 1
Home results since 2008
Home record: 40-49
Longest home winning streak: 5 (2024)
Longest home losing streak: 11 (2016-18), currently 1
Road results since 2008
Road record: 34-57
Longest road winning streak: 5 (2022-23), currently 2
Longest road losing streak: 16 (2016-19)
Regular season results since 2008
Regular season record: 72-102
Longest regular season winning streak: 8 (2022-23), currently 5
Results as an underdog since 2008
Underdog record: 21-93
Longest underdog losing streak: 27 (2016-19), currently 4
Results as a favorite since 2008
Favorite record: 53-13
Longest favorite winning streak: 7 (2025), currently 7
Results when favored by 14+ since 2008
Favorite by 14+ record: 34-4
Longest favorite by 14+ winning streak: 18 (2016-24), currently 3
Offensive streaks since 2008
Scoring 10+ points: 26 (2023-25)
Scoring 20+ points: 11 (2024)
Scoring 30+ points: 7 (2024)
Scoring 40+ points: 3 (2025)
Defensive streaks since 2008
Allowing <40 points: 18 (2009-10), currently 4
Allowing <30 points: 8 (2010), currently 4
Allowing <20 points: 7 (2024)
Allowing <10 points: 7 (2024)
Win margin streaks since 2008
Winning by 10+ points: 7 (2024)
Winning by 20+ points: 7 (2024)
Winning by 30+ points: 3 (2024)
Loss margin streaks since 2008
Losing by 10+ points: 16 (2016-18), currently 1
Losing by 20+ points: 16 (2016-18), currently 1
Losing by 30+ points: 8 (2017-18)
Best game results since 2008
Most points scored: 70 vs Tuscarawas Cent. Cath. [70-40] in 2025
Fewest points allowed: 0 vs Tuscarawas Cent. Cath. [52-0] in 2024
Biggest victory margin: 54 vs opponent [54-0] in 2022
Biggest upset win: underdog by 25 vs East Canton [26-20] in 2022
Worst game results since 2008
Fewest points scored: 0 vs Barnesville [41-0] in 2023
Most points allowed: 68 vs Garaway [68-10] in 2004
Biggest defeat margin: 58 vs Garaway [68-10] in 2004
Biggest upset loss: favored by 29 vs Barnesville [33-8] in 2015
Results vs frequent opponents since 2002
(includes current streak, most recent win & loss)
14-9 (won 4) vs Tuscarawas Cent. Cath., 2025 W 70-40 away, 2021 L 34-0 away
6-17 (won 1) vs Malvern, 2025 W 40-12 away, 2024 L 38-28 away
14-8 (won 5) vs Strasburg-Franklin, 2025 W 38-7 away, 2020 L 28-10 away
1-19 (lost 8) vs Ridgewood, 2013 W 21-6 away, 2025 L 28-6 away
4-14 (lost 6) vs Garaway, 2013 W 15-7 away, 2019 L 35-7 away
15-1 (won 11) vs Conotton Valley, 2025 W 52-20 away, 2006 L 21-13 away
4-11 (lost 2) vs Sandy Valley, 2014 W 20-14 away, 2016 L 29-8 away
1-9 (lost 9) vs Indian Valley, 2003 W 11-6 away, 2022 L 47-16 away
7-3 (won 4) vs East Canton, 2025 W 40-12 away, 2020 L 20-14 away
2-6 (won 1) vs Buckeye Trail, 2025 W 50-6 away, 2024 L 44-28 away
3-3 (lost 2) vs Shenandoah, 2016 W 34-28 away, 2022 L 48-8 away
2-4 (lost 1) vs Caldwell, 2013 W 7-0 away, 2014 L 41-25 away
3-3 (lost 1) vs Claymont, 2024 W 43-8 away, 2025 L 28-14 away
0-5 (lost 5) vs Barnesville, 2023 L 41-0 away
3-2 (won 1) vs Harrison Central, 2025 W 28-21 away, 2005 L 42-0 away
Games not counted by the OHSAA (against Canadian opponents, club teams, etc.) are ignored for these records. In cases where a game was later forfeited (e.g. for an ineligible player), the on-field outcome is still used here. Games against non-OHSAA opponents have no "official" pick, so they will not show up in the favorite or underdog categories.