Drew Pasteur's Ohio Fantastic 50
Ohio High School Football Rankings and Predictions
Follow the Fantastic 50 on Twitter/X for the latest updates.
Scores & schedules courtesy of Joe Eitel
Carlisle Indians history
Updated Mon 03-Nov-2025 11:34 AM
Week 11 complete
Season by season results
2025 9-2, #213, D5 #19
2024 5-6, #363, D5 #46, first round
2023 3-8, #436, D5 #59, first round
2022 4-7, #407, D5 #56, first round
2021 6-6, #290, D5 #29, regional quarters (won 1)
2020 4-6, #506, D5 #70, first round* (won 1)
2019 1-9, #593, D5 #94
2018 0-10, #638, D5 #96
2017 7-3, #322, D5 #30
2016 8-3, #214, D5 #15, regional quarters
2015 6-5, #386, D5 #39, regional quarters
2014 5-5, #330, D4 #49
2013 7-3, #171, D4 #22
2012 8-2, #214, D4 #18
2011 6-4, #230, D4 #25
2010 10-1, #148, D4 #16, regional quarters
2009 9-3, #228, D4 #28, regional semis (won 1)
2008 5-5, #364, D4 #49
2007 5-5
2006 3-7
2005 0-5
2004 6-4, regional quarters
2003 4-6
2002 4-6
Playoff record (since 2002): 4-10
*The 2020 playoffs were open to all teams
Fantastic 50 ranking history
Highest overall ranking: #84 in 2010
Lowest overall ranking: #639 in 2018
Divisional top 10 ranking history
Highest divisional ranking: #10 in 2016
Lowest divisional ranking: #96 in 2018
Total weeks divisionally ranked: 3
Last ranked: 2016
Longest ranked streak: 2 weeks (2010)
Records against F50-ranked teams, 2008-2023
Record vs ranked teams: 0-4
Best win: 2012 #112 Waynesville
Records against divisional top-10 ranked teams, 2008-2023
Record vs ranked teams: 1-11
Best win: 2012 #6 Waynesville
Last ranked win: 2012 #6 Waynesville
Overall results since 2008
Overall record: 103-88
Longest overall winning streak: 10 (2010), currently 5
Longest overall losing streak: 13 (2018-19)
Home results since 2008
Home record: 54-40
Longest home winning streak: 11 (2008-10), currently 3
Longest home losing streak: 6 (2018-19)
Road results since 2008
Road record: 47-44
Longest road winning streak: 8 (2016-17), currently 2
Longest road losing streak: 11 (2017-19)
Regular season results since 2008
Regular season record: 99-79
Longest regular season winning streak: 12 (2009-10), currently 4
Results as an underdog since 2008
Underdog record: 18-71
Longest underdog losing streak: 21 (2017-20)
Results as a favorite since 2008
Favorite record: 85-17
Longest favorite winning streak: 13 (2009-10), currently 9
Results when favored by 14+ since 2008
Favorite by 14+ record: 63-9
Longest favorite by 14+ winning streak: 19 (2008-10), currently 7
Offensive streaks since 2008
Scoring 10+ points: 34 (2010-13), currently 5
Scoring 20+ points: 11 (2016), currently 5
Scoring 30+ points: 5 (2025), currently 5
Scoring 40+ points: 3 (2017)
Defensive streaks since 2008
Allowing <40 points: 15 (2012-14), currently 5
Allowing <30 points: 10 (2013-14), currently 5
Allowing <20 points: 5 (2016), currently 3
Allowing <10 points: 4 (2021), currently 1
Win margin streaks since 2008
Winning by 10+ points: 5 (2025), currently 5
Winning by 20+ points: 3 (2025), currently 1
Winning by 30+ points: 3 (2016), currently 1
Loss margin streaks since 2008
Losing by 10+ points: 9 (2018-19)
Losing by 20+ points: 9 (2018-19)
Losing by 30+ points: 4 (2018)
Best game results since 2008
Most points scored: 75 vs Northridge [75-22] in 2008
Fewest points allowed: 0 vs West Liberty-Salem [35-0] in 2025
Biggest victory margin: 69 vs Arcanum [69-0] in 2008
Biggest upset win: underdog by 19 vs Franklin [34-7] in 2024
Worst game results since 2008
Fewest points scored: 0 vs Waynesville [38-0] in 2023
Most points allowed: 64 vs Brookville [64-45] in 2011
Biggest defeat margin: 54 vs Madison (Middletown) [54-0] in 2018
Biggest upset loss: favored by 26 vs Talawanda [22-21] in 2013
Results vs frequent opponents since 2002
(includes current streak, most recent win & loss)
12-13 (won 1) vs Waynesville, 2025 W 35-14 away, 2024 L 42-14 away
16-7 (won 5) vs Madison (Middletown), 2025 W 46-8 away, 2020 L 30-20 away
17-5 (won 1) vs Northridge, 2024 W 37-30 away, 2023 L 30-22 away
16-3 (won 2) vs Dixie, 2020 W 28-7 away, 2018 L 22-21 away
3-15 (lost 10) vs Brookville, 2010 W 35-7 away, 2025 L 41-7 away
14-3 (won 1) vs Preble Shawnee, 2020 W 20-14 away, 2019 L 52-20 away
10-7 (won 2) vs Oakwood, 2025 W 53-21 away, 2023 L 35-14 away
4-13 (won 2) vs Franklin, 2025 W 21-18 away, 2023 L 26-0 away
3-12 (lost 7) vs Valley View, 2012 W 31-28 away, 2025 L 35-14 away
4-8 (won 1) vs Eaton, 2025 W 35-16 away, 2024 L 34-7 away
4-8 (lost 4) vs Milton-Union, 2016 W 34-28 away, 2020 L 36-20 away
0-6 (lost 6) vs Monroe, 2022 L 32-14 away
4-1 (won 3) vs Arcanum, 2008 W 69-0 away, 2003 L 28-10 away
4-1 (won 1) vs Miami East, 2025 W 25-18 away, 2024 L 52-36 away
Games not counted by the OHSAA (against Canadian opponents, club teams, etc.) are ignored for these records. In cases where a game was later forfeited (e.g. for an ineligible player), the on-field outcome is still used here. Games against non-OHSAA opponents have no "official" pick, so they will not show up in the favorite or underdog categories.